SHOUT OUT FOR EXCELLENT SUPPORT

SHOUT OUT FOR EXCELLENT SUPPORT

I just wanted to say thank you to the Benicia City Council for unanimously voting to fund the repaving project for which we have been clamoring! Did I say the vote was UNANIMOUS?

Thank you Mayor Patterson and the entire City Council.

I would like to especially thank Councilman Tom Campbell for his excellent support. Tom was watching our back at virtually every meeting by keeping it front and center. Thanks Tom! We appreciate your excellent support.

Also, thanks to our Public Works Director, Mr. Graham Wadsworth, for an excellent presentation at the October 18th meeting. You can view it here (fast forward to the 2:17 mark).

http://benicia.granicus.com/MediaPlayer.php?view_id=1&clip_id=232

Great job to all.

VOTE AS IF YOUR STREET DEPENDS ON IT

Dear Friends and Neighbors,

Tomorrow is your day to speak your mind.  I hope that you do, if for no other reason than to respect those that have sacrificed to protect our right to vote.

Thank you for supporting our collective efforts to make Benicia a better place for all of us.

..Ross



Below is a list of
proposed streets scheduled for pavement repair and resurfacing treatment in
2017 between April and October:

2017 Resurface/Reconstruct Streets	Limits
Southampton Road	400’ east of Panorama Dr to Military West
Industrial Way	Lake Herman Road to Teal Street
Teal Drive	Industrial Way to Mallard Dr
East O Street	West of East 3rd Street to East 5th Street
St. Augustine Drive	East 2nd Street to East 3rd Street
Panorama Court	Panorama Dr to end
Merlin Court	Panaroma Dr to end
First Street microsurfacing	K Street to waterfront
Pavement Seal Project	Approximately 700,000 to 1.4 million square feet (SF) on four lane miles of streets

$500,000 FUNDING APPROVED FOR EAST O STREET REPAVING

Mr. Wadsworth,

Thanks for the update and for your efforts and those of the City Council in obtaining the funding to finally repair East O. 


Also, thank you for directing the temporary repairs in the 400 block near the car wash.  We hope that more of the bigger potholes can be filled in the next few weeks as a temporary measure.  They seem to be getting bigger.  Our vehicles and our nerves will appreciate it.

We appreciate your responsiveness.  Thanks again for your help in making Benicia a better place for all of us.

- Ross

On 10/26/2016 2:46 PM, Graham Wadsworth wrote:

Mr. Schwartz, Furtado and Sagun,

I am happy to report that the City Council approved $4.4 million in funding for the 2017 Street Resurfacing Project, which includes removing the existing asphalt concrete on East O Street from 225 west of East 3^rd to East 5^th at a cost of over $500,000. If all goes well with the design and bidding process, then construction should begin during the summer of 2017.

Over the past few weeks, the Street Maintenance crew has placed a thin overlay on part of East O Street and placed a 20’ x 20 pavement patch near the car wash. Over the next few weeks when the weather permits it, they will place more thin overlay to help reduce the risk of potholes forming this winter.

More information about the action that the City Council took on 10/18 can be found at the following web page.

https://legistarweb-production.s3.amazonaws.com/uploads/attachment/pdf/31011/Citywide_Street_Resurfacing_Program_and_Request_for_Funds_-_Staff_Report.pdf

Graham Wadsworth, P. E.

Public Works Director / City Engineer

City of Benicia Public Works Department

250 East "L" Street

Benicia, CA 94510

707-746-4240

gwadsworth@ci.benicia.ca.us

www.ci.benicia.ca.us

ACTION AT LAST!!!! --- O STREET TO BE RESURFACED!!!

Progress at last!

O Street is going to be resurfaced on October 17th and 18th!

Also, Public Works Director, Mr. Graham Wadsworth, informed me today that they are requesting funding for repaving O Street from East 5th to East 3rd.  This is real progress.

Thank you Mr. Wadsworth and to the City Council for helping us make our neighborhood, and Benicia, a better place to live.

Mr. Sagun, A staff report has been prepared for the October 18 City Council meeting recommending that the City Council allocate funding to pave East O Street from East 3^rd to East 5^th. The staff report is available at the following web page: http://www.ci.benicia.ca.us/agendas  Graham Wadsworth, P. E.
Public Works Director / City EngineerCity of Benicia Public Works Department250 East "L" Street
Benicia, CA 94510707-746-4240gwadsworth@ci.benicia.ca.uswww.ci.benicia.ca.us

BREAKING NEWS...CITY COUNCILMAN TOM CAMPBELL BRINGS OUR ISSUE TO THE FOREFRONT!!

Benicia City Councilman Tom Campbell brought our neighborhood's concerns about our streets to the attention of the entire council at their meeting on Tuesday, October 4th.  During the public comment session, Councilman Campbell reminded the council about the need to immediately address the deteriorated conditions in our downtown Benicia neighborhood.  The council was quick to note that they had received "many emails" about our concerns.

Mayor Patterson echoed Councilman Campbell's comments.  Graham Wadsworth, Benicia's Director of Public Works, then gave an update on their proposed timetable to make repairs.  He stated that crews would be out this week to make temporary repairs to East O and East N.  More permanent and substantial repairs and their required funding will be the topic at the next City Council meeting on Tuesday, October 18th.

This is a huge step forward thanks to Tom Campbell. Thank you, Tom, for bringing our concerns to the forefront.  Time will tell if the City is true to its word.

You can view video of Tom's comments on the Benicia's website at http://www.ci.benicia.ca.us/agendas (fast forward to about 1:40 on the tape).

On Oct 8, 2016, at 02:18, Tom Campbell <TCampbell@ci.benicia.ca.us> wrote:

Ross
    Brought the O & N St. roads up in public comment section on Tuesday. You might see what was said. It sounds like the City crew will be out next week for short term work and then at the City Council meeting on 10/18 a long term fix will be on the table. 
Tom

I HOPE THAT THE CITY OF BENICIA HEARS THIS ONE LOUD AND CLEAR! - IT SAYS IT ALL

I receive a lot of comments but this one really says it all.  

If the City of Benicia truly wants to be "ONE OF THE 10 BEST PLACES TO LIVE", they need to pay attention to this one:

"Every time ... and I return home in the evening, we are pretty shocked, slowing to about 10 mph on P [sic] Street to keep our car suspension from being further damaged (both our cars now make strange sounds in the rear suspension). We think -- What sort of town do we have here? Don't we have any pride? What must visitors think of us? (We had better take them the other way to 2nd Street and turn at McDonald's!) For some reason, our city can't take care of even our most basic needs."

 

DID EAST O AND EAST N "SLIP THROUGH THE CRACKS?" - BENICIA PUBLIC WORKS RESPONDS

Graham,

Thank you for the background info on how are streets are supposed to be maintained and repaired.  It all makes good sense to me. 

Did East O and East N just "slip through the cracks"?  They were bad 8 years ago, we reported them several times, and they didn't received any attention. 

I hope that major repairs will be scheduled for the future, next summer as you state.  In the meantime, don't you think some immediate pothole repairs are justified?  Its pretty bad when motorists have to slow to a walking pace or even stop to avoid the holes.

Its unfortunate that our neighborhood's streets have been allowed to deteriorate to such a bad condition and will now need more extensive and unnecessarily expensive attention.  Nevertheless, on behalf of our neighborhood, thank you for looking into the needed repairs. 

Ross

On 10/4/2016 1:49 PM, Graham Wadsworth wrote:

Mr. Sagun,

Benicia does not have the worst streets in Solano County. In the 2015 Pavement Management Plan, the average PCI in Benicia is 58, the average PCI in Suisun City is 55, and the average PCI in Vallejo is 49. Ten years ago, the PCI in Benicia was 70, so there has been a downward trend with a reduction in gas tax revenue.

The first criteria used to determine if a street will be repaved usually starts with the PCI. A street with a PCI less than 25 then the street should be reconstructed, which is 10 to 30 times more expensive than doing preventive maintenance, such as slurry seals and microsurfacing. It is less expensive to keep a street in good condition, than let it deteriorate to the point that it must be reconstructed. This is why you see streets in better condition being repaved. Another reason is that the City receives state funding to pave arterial and collector streets, but not for residential streets. Other criteria include the volume of traffic on the street, the best treatment for the street, and grouping streets with the same treatment in a geographical area for one contractor to resurface, which reduces costs.

In terms of emergency repairs, those are made when there are potholes that need to be filled, which are usually filled in the fall and spring. Potholes are a symptom of a street network that has too much deferred maintenance. I am attaching a file with a list of streets with a PCI less than 20 in case you want to make comparisons. Please note that the street segments are a few blocks long and not uniformly deteriorated, so there may be parts of the segment that are in worse condition than other parts.

I had a meeting today to discuss the available funding for the next street resurfacing project. As I stated in my 9/19 email, City staff will be preparing the paving program this month for construction during the summer of 2017 and East O will be evaluated and considered for inclusion.

Graham

CITY COUNCIL CANDIDATE LIONEL LARGAESPADA WEIGHS IN

Mr. Largaespada,

Thank you for sending your story to us.  We can certainly relate to it.  Those of us that live in the neighborhood bounded by East 2nd - St. Augustine - East 5th - East Military feel like we have been forgotten by our City's leadership.  For eight years we have reported our deteriorating streets with little to show for it, while other neighborhood's get repeated attention.  Why has our neighborhood gone largely unaddressed?  East O near the car wash is the most egregious example and located at a major gateway to Benicia, near hotels and businesses. 


I am embarrassed to drive visitors down these streets.  What must they be thinking?  Doesn't Benicia have any money for street repairs?  Do they even care?  How does this reflect on our City's values and its pride, and what is the effect on our property values? 


It's a mess and I hope that we, and especially our City leaders, can address forthwith.  Thanks again for weighing in and for your support.

..Ross
www.safebenicia.blogspot.com

On 10/4/2016 10:31 AM, Lionel Largaespada, Candidate for Benicia City Council wrote:

Lionel Largaespada, Candidate for Benicia City Council has left a new comment on your post "IT'S DEAD JOE. CAN'T WE GET THIS FIXED?":

While I don’t have a picture, I wanted to share my story with you Ross. This summer, my youngest daughter attended art camp at Robert Semple Elementary. After dropping her off one morning, I decided to drive around the neighborhood because in a few months I would be walking these streets as a candidate for Benicia City Council. To my dismay, I discovered the street conditions were beyond terrible – you would have thought I was driving on a dirt road in the Central Valley (that is NOT meant as an insult to the good people from the 559 area code). Benicia has the second worst roads in all of Solano County—and I agree with you; that’s is unacceptable. While money has been allocated for road repair— I also agree with you that we (i.e. the residents) have been asked to wait too long. That’s why if I am elected to the Benicia City Council, we will make road repair a top priority and we’ll keep repairs at the top of the Measure C project list until it is complete.

Sincerely,
Lionel     

NEWS FLASH!! -- POSSIBLE BREAK IN THE PAVING LOG JAM

Friends and Neighbors,

I just received this potentially good news from Mr. Graham Wadsworth, the Benicia Director of Public Works.  Let's keep our fingers crossed.  Thanks in advance to Mr. Wadsworth and all of you in the background that are helping to make progress and address our neighborhood's concerns.

..Ross

Mr. Wadsworth,
That is excellent news and would be a huge step forward towards addressing our neighborhood's concerns.  We will stand by for the results of their evaluation.  Please keep us advised.
Many thanks.
..Ross
www.safebenicia.blogspot.com

On 10/4/2016 9:57 AM, Graham Wadsworth wrote:
Mr. Sagun, I spoke with the Public Works Street Maintenance Supervisor and the crew began patch paving and filling potholes this month. The crew did what is called a “skin patch” or thin overlay on East O Street near East 5^th Street last year. They will evaluate doing another in the location of the picture that you sent below. If it an appropriate pavement treatment, then they should be able to do the work this month.
 Graham Wadsworth, P. E.
Public Works Director / City EngineerCity of Benicia Public Works Department250 East "L" Street
Benicia, CA 94510707-746-4240gwadsworth@ci.benicia.ca.uswww.ci.benicia.ca.us

IT'S DEAD JOE. CAN'T WE GET THIS FIXED?

Hi Friends and Neighbors,

I can't make the City Council meeting tomorrow night.  If you are going, can you bring this to the Council's attention?  Please remind them that we have been reporting this for 8 years now.  I bet that if this were happening in front of City Hall it would be fixed by now.

Thanks,

Ross

CITY OF BENICIA NEEDS TO KEEP ITS PROMISE TO THE VOTERS - USE MEASURE C FUNDS AS INTENDED

Elizabeth,

Thank you for taking the time to respond to our neighborhood's concerns.  We all realize the funding challenges facing the City.  However, you yourself stated that the City of Benicia committed to the voters that Measure C would be used for pot hole repair.  I challenge anyone to point out a street in Benicia that is as well-traveled as East O from East 5th to East 3rd that is in worse condition.

We are talking about two blocks.  Mr. Wadsworth, the City's Public Works Director, stated himself on 9/19/16 that the street has "failed".  While Southampton Road from Panorama to Hastings is an important artery and needs some repairs, it has not failed.  EAST O HAS FAILED.

NO POTHOLES LIKE THIS ON SOUTHAMPTON ROAD

We urge you and the City to keep your promise to voters to use the funds we voted in for the purpose for which they were intended.  To do otherwise would not be fulfilling of the City of Benicia's responsibility to our City's residents and voters.

We happily noted your commitment to get the discussion rolling within City Hall.  We are anxiously awaiting some results.  Getting a failed street fixed shouldn't be this difficult.

..Ross

On 9/21/2016 11:00 AM, Elizabeth Patterson wrote:

Some people also state all or most of Measure C - thanks to all who voted for our one cent sales tax - can be used for streets.  But that would break our promise of maintaing city services, public safety, parks (library) and fixing pot holes.  We are and will spend some of Measure C on streets, but there is not is not enough in the tax revenues to cover all the needs.  We knew that when we adopted the resolution and anyone who says the Measure C is enough to fix all our roads is wrong.

MAYOR PATTERSON PROMISES ACTION ON OUR CONCERNS

Ross,

First, I am wrong about the last meeting of the month to consider staff recommendations for the road maintenance work. Apparently it will be at an October meeting and I will try to send you a notice.


Right now I don't have all the information I need, but my educated guess is that the maintenance work for Southampton is to keep it from degrading to the point of having to completely reconstruct the road. And from my observation of the road conditions at East O and N and West I and Mills . . . and the list goes on, the road is so bad that it may have to be seriously reconstructed. Again, I am not the expert and these are the questions that we will have when the schedule of road repair is discussed.


I am copying the interim city manager who will be able to give you more firm dates for the council meeting at which we will discuss the situation and give direction to staff.


Take care,


Elizabeth

September 28, 2016 at 1:27 PM

STEVE YOUNG - CITY COUNCIL CANDIDATE - RESPONDS

"now that I have looked at your blog and the pictures, it is hard to understand how the City would not make the repair/rebuilding of this street the highest priority. "

Steve suggests that we get together and show up at the next City Council meeting.  Good idea, but one would think that the City of Benicia wouldn't need a neighborhood revolt to get a street fixed in a timely manner.  After all, we have been waiting for ALMOST A DECADE (since 2008) to get this fixed!  Do you agree?

 --Ross

THE CAR IN FRONT OF ME HAD TO STOP! DUE TO THE POTHOLES

I was driving down East O near the car wash today and following an SUV.  The SUV literally came to a stop to avoid being swallowed by a pothole.  Maybe he was shifting into 4 WHEEL DRIVE!

Sadly, I am not feeling very optimistic about getting any help from the City.  Perhaps I am wrong. Maybe the City will take our suggestion of diverting a small portion of the Measure C funds destined to repave Southampton Road, A ROAD THAT IS MUCH SMOOTHER THAN EAST O.

Call me a pessimist but cars don't have to stop on Southampton Road to avoid road hazards like in OUR NEIGHBORHOOD!

MAYOR PATTERSON RESPONDS AND MY RESPONSE (9/20)

9/20

Ross,

I have a response from interim city manager in response to your first email to me. There is no final decision on this and we will consider our choices the last council meeting this month. 

Elizabeth

9/21

Elizabeth,

Thank you for responding to our concerns about East O and East N Streets.  Mr. Wadsworth, Director of Public Works, stated that a portion of Southampton Road is scheduled to be repaved.  I drove down that portion of Southampton Road yesterday.  It is smoother than a baby's behind compared to East O and East N.  Perhaps the City could take a small portion of those funds and reallocate them.  

We understand that Southampton Road gets a lot of traffic, but what is the rationale for repaving a smooth street when you have streets in an emergency condition?

We will be very interested in the outcome of the upcoming council meeting.
Thanks again.

Ross

IS WAITING UNTIL 2017 ACCEPTABLE? WE HAVE WAITED 8 YEARS TO GET THIS FIXED

Dear Councilmembers,

With all due respect, we do not believe it is an acceptable response to ask us to wait until next year to possibly fix a problem that has been ignored by the City of Benicia for almost a decade.  Have all of you driven down East O Street near the car wash?  It is deplorable, plain and simple.  We need some immediate action to be taken, at least in the 400 block of East O, and respectfully ask for your intervention.

Thanks.

Ross Sagun


www.safebencia.blogspot.com

BENICIA'S PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR RESPONDS - HIS NOTE AND MY RESPONSE

Mr. Wadsworth,

Thank you for your response to our concerns over the deteriorating condition of our neighborhood's streets, specifically, East O and East N Streets.  We have been reporting the poor condition of these streets since at least 2008.  Yet, the City of Benicia has taken virtually no action to repair them.  Our neighborhood feels like we have been ignored and forgotten by the City.

You stated that 35% of Benicia's streets are in "...poor or failed condition."  Is the pavement condition of Benicia's streets the worst streets in Solano County?  What criteria do you use to determine if a street will be repaved?  We have witnessed many of Benicia's streets that are in much better condition being repaved.  When does the deteriorated condition of a street reach the level of requiring emergency repair?  One has to dodge potholes on East O Street near the car wash much like driving down a farmer's dirt road.  One would think that such a deteriorated condition would warrant immediate repair.  We think that the 400 block of East O Street needs immediate repair.  You can visit our website at www.safebenicia.blogspot.com to pictures of the street's failed condition.


While we take pride in our neighborhood, this is not just a nuisance and asthetic issue.  This is a safety issue.  The numerous potholes, cracks, and surface failures that you mentioned can easily cause bicyclists and motorcyclists to lose control, especially in wet conditons.


The area in question is about 4 blocks long.  This would not seem to be a huge project.  We urge you to take immediate action to repair the unacceptable conditions that have been ignored by the City for over 8 years.  Anything less would not be fulfilling the City's responsibility to Benicia's businesses and residents.

We look forward to your answers to our questions.  Thank you again for your response. 

Ross Sagun

www.safebenicia.blogspot.com

On 9/19/2016 11:51 AM, Graham Wadsworth wrote:

Mr. Sagun,

I drove on East N and East O Streets, and looked up the Pavement Condition Index (PCI), which are 27 and 35, respectively. The streets have deep longitudinal cracks, alligator cracking, and surface failures. It appears that the City has done some patch paving on these streets in the past. The Public Works crew fills potholes in the fall before the winter rains begin, so I am copying the Superintendent for his information.

The Metropolitan Transportation Commission classifies a PCI less than 25 out of 100 as a “very poor / failed” street, and recommends that the street be reconstructed. The portion of East O between East 4^th and East 5^th appears to have reached this level. On page 8 of the attached City Manager’s Report, it states that 70 out of 200 miles (or 35%) of City streets are in poor or failed condition. With a decrease in Gas Tax funding over the past 20 years, there is more work to do than funding available to fix the City’s streets.

The City used Measure C sales tax revenue to hire a contractor to do some patch paving work on streets south if I-780 within the past year, but I did not see any recent patches on these streets. Measure C funding will be used to pave Southampton Road from Hastings Drive to the new pavement near Panorama Drive.  In October, City staff will be preparing a paving program to use the available funding as cost effectively as possible to stretch the dollars as far as possible. East O Street is already on the Pavement Repair Request Log. By copy of this email, I am asking Lisa to add East N Street to the Log. We plan to hire a contractor to do more patch paving in 2017, so we will see if there are places on East N and East O Streets where that makes sense.

The paving program will be used to recommend projects in the Fiscal Year 2017-19 Budget. If you would like more information about the paving program, feel free to contact Steve Yee at the email above or 746-4240.

Graham Wadsworth, P. E.

Public Works Director / City Engineer

City of Benicia Public Works Department

250 East "L" Street

Benicia, CA 94510

707-746-4240

gwadsworth@ci.benicia.ca.us

www.ci.benicia.ca.us

East O Street near the car wash - nice huh?

BENICIA CITY COUNCIL - RESPONSIVE OR SILENT? YOU BE THE JUDGE

Here's the responsiveness score so far:


Tom Campbell - RESPONDED! (9/16)

Christina Strawbridge - RESPONDED! (9/17)

Mark Hughes - RESPONDED!  (9/19)



Elizabeth Patterson - SILENT

Alan Schwartzman - SILENT

CHRISTINA STRAWBRIDGE RESPONDS!

Kudos to Councilmember Christina Strawbridge for her timely response:

I am forwarding your e-mail to our City Manager for information on where we are on road improvements. With Measure C money we have been able to address our roads in Benicia.

Thank you,
Christina 

SOMEONE AT CITY HALL IS LISTENING TO US! HOORAY!

KUDOS TO COUNCILMAN TOM CAMPBELL





I'll send this to the city manager and ask him what's planned. I'll try and get back to you when I know something.

Tom


From: Ross Sagun
Sent: Friday, September 16, 2016 7:35:55 PM
To: Tom Campbell
Subject: deteriorating street condition


Councilman Campbell:

Here is a copy of a letter that I sent to Mayor Patterson. We are asking for your help and support to address this problem. We know that this is a busy time for you but hope that you will share our concerns about this longstanding problem.

Thank you.

Ross Sagun

www.safebenicia.blogspot.com

DO YOUR TEETH FALL OUT WHEN DRIVING DOWN EAST O STREET? AN OPEN LETTER TO MAYOR PATTERSON

September 16, 2016



Dear Mayor Patterson:



I would like to bring to your attention an important issue on behalf of my friends and neighbors living in the Harborview Knolls neighborhood. That issue is the serious deterioration of the streets in our neighborhood, specifically, the following:


East O Street from East Fifth Street to East Third Street


East N Street from East Fifth Street to East Third Street



The pavement on these streets is seriously failing, and in some cases such as the section of East O near the carwash has completely failed, with cracks up to 6 inches, potholes, and erosion. These defects pose a safety hazard, especially to motorcyclists in the winter when the streets are wet. One must slow to a crawl to drive a car along the street to avoid serious vibration. We have seen motorists driving in the opposite lane to avoid potholes. It is literally like driving on a dirt road.


These streets get a substantial amount of traffic and are located at a major gateway to Benicia (East Fifth Street off-ramp). East N Street goes right past the Holiday Inn Express, giving visitors and tourists a first-hand look at the disrepair of Benicia’s streets. East O is adjacent to a popular carwash, auto parts store, and child care center, as well as high density housing.


We reported this to the City of Benicia as early as April 2008 but little has been done to repair these streets. All the while, we notice less traveled and streets in better condition, such as East J and K Streets east of East Fifth Street, getting repaved. We feel like we have been forgotten.


Could you please look into this for us? Just take a drive down East O from East Fifth to East Third and you will see just exactly what we are talking about.


Thank you in advance for your attention and any help that you can offer.




Sincerely yours,

Ross Sagun

www.safebenicia.blogspot.com



cc: Vice Mayor Mark Hughes

Councilman Tom Campbell

Councilman Alan Schwartzman

Councilwoman Christina Strawbridge